Skip to main content
EnrollMedicare.com - Sign up for Medicare with confidence

Medicare Agents in Indianapolis, Indiana

Top-rated Medicare insurance agents near you, ranked by Google reviews. Agents can't pay to be listed here.

Top Medicare Agents

10 agents found

The Medicare Family

Health insurance agency

5.0(4,100 reviews)
Noblesville, IN

Closed · Opens 9 AM

The Insurance Workshop | Medicare Insurance Advisors

Health insurance agency

5.0(481 reviews)
New Albany, IN

Closed · Opens 9 AM

Easy Street Insurance

Health insurance agency

5.0(340 reviews)
Indianapolis, IN

Closed · Opens 9 AM

Howard Medicare and Health Insurance

Health insurance agency

5.0(248 reviews)
Carmel, IN

Closed · Opens 6 AM

Henderson & Walters Agency, LLC

Health insurance agency

5.0(247 reviews)
Fort Wayne, IN

Closed · Opens 8 AM

HealthMarkets Insurance - Kevin McIntire

Health insurance agency

5.0(143 reviews)
Auburn, IN

Gordon Marketing

Insurance broker

5.0(141 reviews)
Noblesville, IN

Closed · Opens 8 AM

HealthMarkets Insurance - Staci Lepsky Insurance Agency

Insurance agency

5.0(133 reviews)
Indianapolis, IN

Closed · Opens 8:30 AM

Heartland Health Insurance

Health insurance agency

5.0(130 reviews)

Closed · Opens 9 AM

Indiana Health Advisors - Medicare & Health Insurance

Health insurance agency

4.9(108 reviews)
Muncie, IN

Closed · Opens 9 AM

Not sure who to contact?

Our team can review your situation and help you find the right Medicare plan — no pressure, no obligation.

Get Free Help

Medicare Information for Indianapolis

Learn about Medicare enrollment, local resources, and coverage options in Indianapolis.

View Medicare Guide for Indianapolis

Why work with a Medicare agent?

A licensed agent can help you navigate enrollment, compare plans, and avoid costly mistakes — all at no cost to you.

  1. 1
    It's completely free — Agents are paid by insurance companies, not you.
  2. 2
    They know Indianapolis — Local agents understand which plans work best with doctors and hospitals in your area.
  3. 3
    They handle the paperwork — From enrollment forms to plan changes, they make sure everything is filed correctly.
Real reviews only

Rankings come straight from Google. No paid placements.

No hidden costs

Agents don't pay us. You get unbiased recommendations.

Licensed pros

Every agent is licensed to sell Medicare plans in Indiana.

Mon–Fri 8am–8pm ET • Sat 10am–6pm ET