Skip to main content
EnrollMedicare.com - Sign up for Medicare with confidence

Medicare Agents in New York, New York

Top-rated Medicare insurance agents near you, ranked by Google reviews. Agents can't pay to be listed here.

Top Medicare Agents

10 agents found

MetroPlusHealth HQ

Health insurance agency

4.6(1,500 reviews)
New York, NY

Open · Closes 5 PM

CoverRight

Health insurance agency

4.9(262 reviews)
Brooklyn, NY

Open · Closes 10 PM

Mindful Medicare Solutions

Health insurance agency

5.0(250 reviews)
West Hempstead, NY

Open · Closes 6:30 PM

The Medicare Group

Insurance agency

4.9(239 reviews)
West New York, NJ

Open · Closes 5:30 PM

Flatbush Insurance Services - Medicare, Health Insurance & Life Insurance

Insurance agency

5.0(223 reviews)
Brooklyn, NY

Open · Closes 11:30 PM

Jeff Waddle Ins Agency Inc

Health insurance agency

4.9(166 reviews)
New York, NY

Open · Closes 5 PM

Craig Smith Insurance- Specializing in Medicare

Health insurance agency

5.0(162 reviews)

Open · Closes 8 PM

Craig Smith Insurance- Specializing in Medicare

Health insurance agency

5.0(152 reviews)
New York, NY

Open · Closes 8 PM

Greenpoint Insurance Brokerage

Insurance broker

4.9(146 reviews)
Brooklyn, NY

Open · Closes 7 PM

Understand Medicare Now Inc.

Insurance broker

5.0(142 reviews)
New York, NY

Open · Closes 6 PM

Not sure who to contact?

Our team can review your situation and help you find the right Medicare plan — no pressure, no obligation.

Get Free Help

Medicare Information for New York

Learn about Medicare enrollment, local resources, and coverage options in New York.

View Medicare Guide for New York

Why work with a Medicare agent?

A licensed agent can help you navigate enrollment, compare plans, and avoid costly mistakes — all at no cost to you.

  1. 1
    It's completely free — Agents are paid by insurance companies, not you.
  2. 2
    They know New York — Local agents understand which plans work best with doctors and hospitals in your area.
  3. 3
    They handle the paperwork — From enrollment forms to plan changes, they make sure everything is filed correctly.
Real reviews only

Rankings come straight from Google. No paid placements.

No hidden costs

Agents don't pay us. You get unbiased recommendations.

Licensed pros

Every agent is licensed to sell Medicare plans in New York.

Mon–Fri 8am–8pm ET • Sat 10am–6pm ET